Which Animal Hair is Best for Makeup Brushes?

Choosing the right animal hair¹ for your brushes feels overwhelming. A wrong choice can ruin product performance and waste your budget. This guide simplifies it for you.

The best animal hair depends on use: goat for everyday powders (pickup and spring), squirrel for ultra-soft, sheer finishing, and kolinsky/weasel for precise eye and lip work, especially with creams. Choose hair by formula and finish—not just by price.

When I first started on the factory floor, I saw firsthand how a small change in hair type could completely transform a brush’s performance. A brand would order a "soft" brush without specifying the hair, and the result wouldn’t work with their finely-milled powder. They were frustrated, and the factory had to remake the order. These are costly mistakes that can delay your launch.

Understanding the specific jobs of each hair type is the single most important step in developing a high-performance brush line. It’s not about finding one "best" hair; it’s about building a toolkit where every brush does its job perfectly. Let’s break down the key players so you can source with confidence.

Goat vs. Squirrel vs. Kolinsky: How Do You Match Hair to Formula and Finish?

Picking between goat, squirrel, and kolinsky can feel like a guess. Guessing wrong leads to poor makeup application and unhappy customers. Let’s map each hair to its perfect use.

Match hair to the job. Use goat for daily powders that need good pickup, squirrel for a sheer, delicate finish, and weasel or kolinsky for precise control with creams and liners.

The secret to a perfect brush isn’t just softness—it’s how the hair’s structure interacts with a specific makeup formula. As a brand founder, knowing this helps you write better product specifications and avoid costly sampling errors. I always advise my clients to think about the finish they want to achieve first, then select the hair. A sheer, diffused highlight requires a completely different tool than a sharp, graphic eyeliner. Here’s a simple breakdown I use with my clients to guide their sourcing decisions.

Hair Type and Its Best Use

Think of these hairs as specialists. You wouldn’t use a hammer to turn a screw. In the same way, you shouldn’t use a squirrel brush for packing on pigment.

Grades and Blends Decoded: What Do XGF, Saikoho, and Blends Mean for Your Budget?

hair grades² like Saikoho and XGF sound complex. Not knowing them means you might overpay for the wrong quality or get a brush that feels prickly and sheds.

Grades indicate softness, which comes from the part of the hair used. First-cut tips are softest and costliest. Blends balance performance and price, like mixing goat and squirrel hair³.

When you get a quote from a factory, the price difference often comes down to the hair grade. I remember a client who wanted to create a "dupe" of a luxury brush but at a lower cost. The original used Saikoho goat hair⁴. My client’s initial budget only allowed for a lower grade. The first sample felt scratchy, and she was disappointed. I explained that the original brush used "first-cut" tips—the very finest, naturally tapered end of the hair. Her sample used a lower cut, which is thicker and blunter.

Understanding Cuts and Grades

• First-Cut vs. Lower-Cut: First-cut hair is the untrimmed, natural tip. It’s the softest and most expensive part. Hair cut from further down the shaft is coarser and less flexible. This is a major factor in shedding and that "prickly" feeling.
• Goat Hair Grades (Sokoho/Saikoho): These are Japanese terms that have become an industry standard for quality. Sokoho is high-quality goat hair, great for many applications. Saikoho is even finer and softer, often from a specific part of the goat, making it more luxurious and expensive. Other grades like XGF or ZGF are also used by suppliers to classify softness and length. Always ask your supplier what their grading system means.

The Smart Use of Blends

Blend engineering is where manufacturing expertise really shines. We can create a custom feel and performance while managing costs. For example, pure squirrel is very expensive and can be too floppy for some uses. By blending it with a small amount of high-quality goat hair, we increase its spring and powder pickup while keeping it very soft. This gives you a high-performance brush at a more accessible price point.

Ethics and Compliance: Are Your ‘Cruelty-Free’ Brushes Actually Compliant?

You want to claim "cruelty-free⁵," but you don’t have the right documents. A false claim can destroy your brand’s reputation with customers who value transparency.

The EU’s 2013 animal testing ban is a marketing rule, not a supply chain certification. To truly claim ‘cruelty-free,’ you need audited programs like Leaping Bunny to verify your sources.

This is one of the biggest areas of confusion I see with brand founders, especially those targeting the US and EU markets. Many believe that because their final product isn’t tested on animals, they can automatically label their natural hair brushes "cruelty-free." This is a dangerous assumption. Your customers, particularly in today’s market, expect that claim to cover the entire supply chain. I worked with a brand that almost launched with a "cruelty-free" claim based on their supplier’s verbal promise. I pushed them to ask for documentation, and the supplier couldn’t provide it. We had to switch vendors, which delayed the launch but saved their brand’s integrity.

Differentiating Bans from Certifications

• EU 2013 Ban: This is a marketing ban. It prohibits the sale of cosmetics and ingredients that were tested on animals after that date. It does not automatically certify that the animal hair used in your brushes was sourced without harm to the animal. It’s a common and costly misunderstanding.
• Audited Programs (Leaping Bunny): Certifications like Leaping Bunny go much deeper. They require a brand to implement a supplier monitoring system. They enforce a "fixed cut-off date," meaning no animal testing is allowed in any part of the supply chain after that date. Most importantly, they conduct independent audits to verify these claims. This is the level of proof your brand needs to make a credible cruelty-free claim.

As a brand owner, it’s your responsibility to demand supply chain transparency from your factory. Ask for documentation. If they can’t provide it, they are not the right partner for a brand built on trust.

Factory-Floor QA: How Can You Verify Hair Type and Prevent Shedding?

You worry your supplier might switch materials between the sample and bulk production. Poor quality control leads to shedding, bleeding dye, and angry customers who demand refunds.

Use simple factory-floor tests⁶ to confirm quality. Microscopy checks for hair cuticles, a burn test identifies material, and standardized tests can measure shedding, dye bleed, and ferrule strength.

After you’ve approved a perfect sample, how do you ensure the 10,000 brushes in your bulk order are identical? This is where factory-floor quality assurance⁷ becomes your best friend. When I ran my own factory, we had a strict QA protocol for every single order. These aren’t complex lab procedures; they are practical tests that any good manufacturing partner should be performing. As a brand owner, you should know what these tests are so you can ask your supplier about their process. It shows you’re an informed buyer and holds them accountable.

Key QA Checks for Brush Quality

1. hair verification⁸: How do you know you got goat hair and not a cheaper synthetic blend?

   • Microscopy: This is the most reliable way. Animal hair has a scaly cuticle structure, while synthetic fibers are perfectly smooth.
   • Burn/Singe Test: A small, controlled test. A few strands of animal hair will singe, curl, and smell like burnt hair. Synthetics will melt and often form a hard bead.

2. Shedding and Durability:

   • Shed Rate Test: We run a new brush over a textured surface or use a standardized machine to count how many hairs fall out in the first few uses. A well-made brush should have minimal shedding.
   • Ferrule Crimp Integrity: The ferrule is the metal part that holds the hair. We perform a pull test to ensure it’s securely crimped to the handle and that the glue is holding the hair bundle firmly.

3. Dye Bleed: If your brush hairs are dyed (e.g., black goat hair), you must check for dye fastness. We simply wash the brush head with a mild solvent or soap and check for any color bleeding onto a white cloth. This prevents your customers from having a nasty surprise during their first wash.

Conclusion

Choosing the right animal hair is about matching the tool to the task. Understand the function of each hair type to build a brush line that performs beautifully and builds brand trust.

References